Home

Robert Pattinson tapped to be the next James Bond is a waste of his talent after massive generational run

Headshot of Wenlei Ma
Wenlei MaThe Nightly
Robert Pattinson
Camera IconRobert Pattinson Credit: The Nightly

The question of who would be the new Bond has been hanging around since Daniel Craig was still halfway through his tenure.

Even 15 years ago, as Robert Pattinson was doing promo work for the Twilight movies, he was already been asked by reporters if he had any interest in the role. Just as every young British actor who vaguely “looked” the part had.

With Pattinson now confirmed to be stepping into the iconic role, consider the betting markets quietened, at least for now. Of course, it won’t be long before the cycle starts all over again.

Pattinson is the most and the least exciting choice to be the current era Bond.

The most because the British actor, 40, has the action chops, the dramatic weight and even the comedic timing for a super spy that can kill, romance and wink with conviction at any villain or potential paramour.

He has a wiliness and adaptability that has worked for him across genres, and will for anything mission-related Bond needs to do. And layers of softness and playfulness that contrasts with the masculine rigidity Craig’s Bond could sometimes be – different iterations of the character has often swung like a pendulum.

Already there are some complaints online that Pattinson isn’t “alpha male” enough, but that’s the last thing Bond should be in a manosphere moment. Large swathes of the audience is sick of a severe definition of manhood that serves no one except the most deluded.

Pattinson can also handle the rigours of franchise filmmaking, having been put through his paces over four Twilight films as a young star and more recently as Batman (it does seem less likely that a Batman 3 will happen now).

VideoRobert Pattinson being tapped as the next James Bond is a ‘waste of his talent’, argues Culture Editor Wenlei Ma, who says the 007 spy role will be a cakewalk for The Odyssey, Primetime and Dune star.

He’s known for not loving the all-consuming demands of a large press tour, but when you see him in action, he’s also brilliant at it. Pattinson will be a great ambassador for the Bond brand because he understands the job, and he’s under no illusions about what being Bond entails.

Last week, I wrote that Pattinson is the man for the role, but that doesn’t mean he should do it – and I still stand by it. He’s on a creative high in his career, and Bond needs him more than he needs Bond.

Coming off the back of a year which consisted of The Odyssey, Primetime, The Drama and the upcoming Dune Part 3, on which he worked with the new Bond director Denis Villeneuve, he could have his pick of projects right now.

Robert Pattinson in Dune Part 3.
Camera IconRobert Pattinson in Dune Part 3. Credit: Warner Bros/YouTube

He could throw his stardom and greenlight power behind an auteur indie filmmaker, the kind he’s been working with for more than a decade, turning in eccentric performances in even stranger films.

Taking Pattinson out of that ecosystem is a waste of his talent. Bond is a cakewalk for Pattinson, he’s essentially already played that role for Christopher Nolan in Tenet. But making another film in a similar vein to what he did for Claire Denis in High Life or for Robert Eggers in The Lighthouse, that’s where Pattinson eats.

Still, what’s done is done, and, the good news is that Pattinson won’t be stuck in this forever. If anything, he might be committed for a shorter run than his competitors were.

Puck News had reported late last week that Pattinson’s deal consisted of only three movies, a condition that was offered only to him. The others, which reportedly included Josh O’Connor (who apparently took himself out of the running), Jack Lowden, Callum Turner and Nicholas Hoult, were committed for four films.

Those contract terms suggested that Villeneuve and producers David Heyman (who produced all the Harry Potter movies, where Pattinson got his break) Amy Pascal were really keen on Pattinson, and were willing to bend to make it happen. Puck also reported that his compensation was much more generous.

So, in theory, he could be in and out in under a decade before he turns 50, maybe even in six or seven years if they film a couple back-to-back, which is the best thing for his career. That his team was able to make that deal is also good news because it means that maybe he won’t be commoditised to the same degree as someone with less negotiating power.

That’s also good for the Bond brand. We can deal with the character selling high-end watches, but no one wants to see him schilling pre-mixed Vesper martinis in a can and Kindle devices or, god forbid, become a cheerleader for Amazon’s $US50 billion-dollar investment in OpenAI.

Robert Pattinson as Chris Hansen in Primetime.
Camera IconRobert Pattinson as Chris Hansen in Primetime. Credit: Supplied/TheWest

With the Walther PPK in Pattinson’s hand, we can guess at what the new era of Bond might look like – and that’s the “least exciting” part in terms of choosing him.

Pattinson has the look and the vibe of a Bond, which is why when his name was thrown into the race late in the game, it made a lot of sense. A classically handsome Brit with a cheeky sense of fun as well as gravitas, he is what you expect.

Which suggests that the new era of Bond is also what you might expect.

Pattinson might have a history of playing quirky characters and being unafraid to come off dirty, compromised or crazy on screen, but that’s not what Bond is. So, with him in the role, the odds of bold creative swings seems low, which is also not Villeneuve’s style either.

The French-Canadian filmmaker is a wonderful visualist and an imaginative filmmaker, but we’ve seen with his stewardship of the Dune franchise that he has a lot of reverence for the source material. He can enhance and he can elevate but he’s not going to go completely wild and take it in a different direction. He’s not going to David Lynch this joint.

James Bond is one of the most venerated icons of British pop culture, and there were always going to be limits as to how far anyone is allowed to push it.

Sean Connery as James Bond.
Camera IconSean Connery as James Bond. Credit: Bert Cann/Supplied

The filmmakers may have had the character do all kinds of wacky stuff during the Roger Moore years, but in the decades since, Bond has only grown in cultural significance. You wouldn’t get away with an Octopussy or Moonraker now, and not just the sexual politics.

It is one of the few remaining globally recognisable brands that still has the soft power to actually symbolise something - an idea of Britain in the world as a consequential power and a force for good, and in a post-Brexit reality that perception is even more important to sell.

Bond might now be controlled by an American conglomerate with an owner who probably has no interest in propping up the myths of an old empire whose “best” days went out of fashion along with the supremacy of naval armadas, but Amazon understands the commercial realities of not rocking the boat.

It would be sensitive to how much Bond means to the British cultural establishment, and how much the rest of the world expects it to represent the same. It’s likely why they put Heyman, one of the UK’s best known producers, in charge along with Pascal.

It’s also likely why it recruited Steven Knight, who has penned the likes of Peaky Blinders and Spencer, to write the screenplay. So, you can have a French-Canadian as director and you can be owned by the Americans as long as you put a British infrastructure around them.

Daniel Craig played Bond in five films.
Camera IconDaniel Craig played Bond in five films. Credit: AAP

It’s why the likes of Australian Jacob Elordi was never in serious contention. It was never enough to be from the wider Commonwealth. Nor was there any real momentum behind non-white British actors such as Riz Ahmed, Daniel Kaluuya or Dev Patel who all would’ve been very dapper in that tuxedo.

It’s an indictment that if anyone other than a straight white man had been cast as Bond, it would’ve been labelled “controversial”. The formula of Bond equals Britain means having to adhere to an outdated idea of British versus what it actually means.

It sucks, and there’s a lot of “it is what it is”, but the fact that the final field consisted of five men who looked not dissimilar represents where we still are, and it doesn’t reflect on us well.

So, it had to play out this way.

As much as we all have a relationship with Bond that is specific to each person, what the character is to Amazon is a commercial entity.

The company spent $US8.5 billion in 2022 to buy MGM Studios, which had a 50 per cent financial stake and the distribution rights to the films. Eon Productions, then run by Barbara Broccoli and her stepbrother Michael G. Wilson, held the other 50 per cent but had full creative control.

Robert Pattinson is Antinous in The Odyssey.
Camera IconRobert Pattinson is Antinous in The Odyssey. Credit: Melinda Sue Gordon/Universal Pic/Melinda Sue Gordon

Bond was easily the jewel in MGM’s crown, and arguably, a not insignificant chunk of that deal was for the rights to the super spy, and Amazon was eager to start collecting on their expensive investment.

But in the years following the acquisition, Amazon and Eon couldn’t agree on what the next chapter of Bond looked like. The American e-commerce retailer and tech company wanted to expand the brand into spin-offs and extensions, unsatisfied with Broccoli’s insistence that it should stay the course of a new movie every three to four years.

Amazon eventually bought out Eon’s creative control, but not before the behind-the-scenes scuffles broke out into the press. Which invites even more scrutiny of what Amazon will now do with Bond, which was already starting from behind given it’s an American tech company, and no one likes those guys right now.

So, it has to be eager to please, and putting Villeneuve, Heyman, Pascal and Knight in charge of the first film of the new era were smart choices. Now, Pattinson as Bond is a combination that will genuinely be what the industry terms a “four-quadrant” project, as in, something for everyone.

Bond already means something to older Millennials and up, they all grew up with a version of Bond, “their” Bond, whether it was Sean Connery, George Lazenby, Roger Moore, Timothy Dalton, Pierce Brosnan or Craig.

Robert Pattinson and John David Washington in Tenet. Pattinson played a similar role to Bond in the Christopher Nolan movie.
Camera IconRobert Pattinson and John David Washington in Tenet. Pattinson played a similar role to Bond in the Christopher Nolan movie. Credit: Warner Bros.

And after the years-long hoopla over the casting, the curiosity factor is high. This is the most zeitgeisty the franchise has been this side of the millennium.

But it also needed renewal, it needed that younger audience to embrace it. For younger Millennials and older Gen Z-ers, Pattinson’s work in Twilight and Harry Potter will bring them in. He also gets the cinephiles and the younger Gen Z-ers because Pattinson’s work with indie filmmakers is legendary.

He’s also a wild and zany presence online with his press tour videos frequently going viral – just rewatch the one where he insists he’s Gen Z to a disbelieving Jennifer Lawrence.

Bond has traditionally been someone with a lower profile, which is why Pattinson wasn’t in the public conversations and lists, but Amazon has clearly decided they wanted someone who was already properly famous.

In that sense, he is the safe choice – extremely British in a prosaic, uncontroversial way, creatively talented and a global star.

The best man for the job because the job has so many parameters.

Get the latest news from thewest.com.au in your inbox.

Sign up for our emails