
5 stars
Starring: Elizabeth Holmes, Nathan Fielder, Lance Oppenheim
Rating: M
In cinemas: Now
Believe the hype. Embrace the memes. You Can See Everything is the best film of the year, and if it doesn’t win the Oscar for best picture it’s because a few fuddy-duddies in the Academy couldn’t get their heads around it.
In 20 years of reviewing films, this critic has never once awarded a five-star review, and he sure didn’t think that streak would be broken by a Nathan Fielder meta-documentary that fulfils every A24 trope.
And about Elizabeth Holmes, of all people, the convicted fraud behind med-tech flop Theranos, who has been covered ad nauseam.
But here we are.
Fielder, the deadpan king of cringe, has built an enviable reputation (albeit to a niche audience) through his reality show, Nathan For You, and its successor, the acclaimed docu-comedy series, The Rehearsal.

He and buddy Lance Oppenheim, who just released the excellent Chris Hansen biopic, Primetime, arrived at the Holmes project in 2023 after it had already been pitched to the studio by the Theranos founder’s baby daddy, Billy Evans (more on him later).
They had 34 days until Holmes was due to begin what was originally an 11-year sentence in prison for defrauding investors of $US452 million ($657m).
For motivations that are unpacked effectively in the film, Holmes and Evans allowed Fielder to live in their San Diego home, filming almost 24/7, as the couple raised two young children, prepared for the looming incarceration and, incredibly, planned Theranos 2.0.
This jaw-dropping level of access to one of the tech boom’s most notorious and downright weirdest characters would be compelling enough but add Fielder into the mix as an on-screen presence and you end up with something truly riveting.
A classic A24-tinged shot of Holmes going about her life, would suddenly include the Canadian comedian appearing in the background, like a jump-scare of awkwardness, in a way that is genuinely hilarious.
Fielder’s trademark deadpan delivery is also the perfect foil to Holmes’ inimitable earnestness, reflecting the audience’s disbelief at the things coming out of her mouth.
Perhaps “inimitable” is not the correct word, considering actor Amanda Seyfried appears when Holmes goes to prison halfway through the film, reprising a version of the Theranos founder we saw in her hit biopic series, The Dropout.
Seyfried’s role here is spectacularly well conceived, as we begin to see the true colours of Evans, who is very obviously portrayed as the villain of the piece.
One of the biggest achievements of this film is it fully justifies its near-three-hour runtime, and, in fact, will leave you wanting even more.
Absolute perfection. Fielder is no longer just the king of cringe. All hail the new king of Hollywood.

Get the latest news from thewest.com.au in your inbox.
Sign up for our emails