Home

Cricket Australia confirm fresh independent ‘forum’ will be held into 2018 sandpaper scandal

Headshot of Josh Kempton
Josh KemptonThe West Australian
VideoAfter hailing the team and wider organisation’s turnaround in culture since 2018, Cricket Australia’s chief executive Todd Greenberg has outlined how the forum will be conducted.

Cricket Australia have confirmed a fresh independent “forum” will be conducted into the events of the 2018 sandpaper scandal, but an investigation concluded in South Africa at the time will not be reopened.

And both chief executive Todd Greenberg and chairman David Boon revealed they are uncertain on the accuracy of the findings of the initial review, which determined only Cam Bancroft, Steve Smith and David Warner had knowledge of a ball tampering plot.

Meanwhile, Warner and Usman Khawaja — who have spent recent weeks publicly tearing down CA’s official narrative of the infamous events — both expressed doubt over whether the forum would come any closer to helping achieve a consensus on the saga.

Earlier this month, Khawaja came forward with an account of the happenings in South Africa which stands in stark contrast to CA’s, saying the entire team was aware of plans to tamper with the ball and the Cape Town Test was not the first time it had occured.

His allegations have divided the team and Australian cricket. Bowler Pat Cummins — who has since been appointed as the side’s captain — dismissed Khawaja’s version of events as “complete and utter nonsense” on Friday morning.

After days of speculation, Boon was the first of CA’s leadership pair to address a pack of reporters in Hobart on Wednesday afternoon, saying the CA board had determined it was “time for a circuit-breaker”.

“After careful discussion, we agreed to establish a forum which will allow players and staff involved in the events in South Africa in 2018 to share their experiences and their perspectives,” Boon said.

“For almost a decade, the fallout from these events has remained part of the conversation around Australian cricket. It has been a difficult chapter for many people, and increasingly, the ongoing debate has become a distraction for our game.

“It’s about creating an opportunity for those who wish to be heard to tell their stories in a respectful, safe environment, and for our sport to listen.

“Australian cricket is at its strongest when we are united, and we owe it to everyone who loves the game to make every reasonable effort to move forward together, with understanding, respect and perspective.”

No fresh sanctions will be levelled against any player or CA staff member as a result of the forum, with a determination on whether its findings are made public to be made after its conclusion.

“It’s not a reinvestigation, it’s not designed to reprosecute or to sanction. No one is compelled to participate, it is entirely up to each individual,” Greenberg said.

Greenberg says no fresh sanctions will be levelled as part of the sandpaper forum.
Camera IconGreenberg says no fresh sanctions will be levelled as part of the sandpaper forum. Credit: Robert Cianflone/Getty Images

Khawaja said he would “support the board”, but he wished they had acted sooner and he held doubts over whether the forum would lead to any kind of resolution.

“It’s hard to get the whole truth unless everyone is speaking, support staff and players,” Khawaja told Fox Cricket.

“If you leave that open-ended, what are you finding?

“The biggest question I had . . . the board makes the decision on what comes out at the end. How is that an actual way of presenting what people actually said?

“I appreciate where their heart is . . . I respect what he (Greenberg) is trying to do there.

“But I think, at the end of the day, if you’re gonna cherry pick what is said, in this (report) . . . the board can choose whatever they want to come in or come out, are we just going in a circle here?”

Warner said he had no qualms with the decision to not level fresh sanctions against players or staff as a result of the forum’s findings, saying uncovering the truth was more important.

“We (Warner, Smith and Bancroft) put our hands up, we accepted what Cricket Australia handed down to us,” Warner said.

Warner and Khawaja both expressed doubts over whether CA’s forum would lead to a resolution.
Camera IconWarner and Khawaja both expressed doubts over whether CA’s forum would lead to a resolution. Credit: Robert Cianflone/Getty Images

“It’s not about penalties. It’s just about coming up with transparency and accountability . . . It’s about the Australian public, about the fans of the game, and we want to see that.

“Yes, people want to talk about moving on. But in this safe environment, we want every single person that’s there to be able to speak.”

Remarkably, both Greenberg and Boon conceded they had no certainty if the knowledge of using sandpaper extended beyond Warner, Smith and Bancroft, which was the conclusion drawn from Cricket Australia’s investigation at the time.

“I don’t know the answer to that question,” Greenberg conceded.

“I wasn’t there, so how can I comment? I don’t know,” Boon later added.

Neither Greenberg nor Boon were in their positions at the time of the scandal.

Greenberg said the forum will be conducted by a King’s Counsel or “someone of that ilk” and did not put a timeline on its completion, while expressing doubt it would be wrapped up before the start of the Test summer on December 9.

VideoAfter hailing the team and wider organisation’s turnaround in culture since 2018, Cricket Australia’s chief executive Todd Greenberg has outlined how the forum will be conducted.

On Wednesday morning, Australian cricket great Ian Healy took aim at Warner, Khawaja and one-Test seamer Chadd Sayers for coming forward with contrasting accounts eight years after the events, saying players from the infamous tour would now be branded as “liars forever”.

“They didn’t come forward when it was saveable, now there’s a massive stain on cricket, and they’ll be known as liars forever,” Healy told SEN.

“There is no reason this should have been rehashed. This was not (Khawaja’s) story to tell, he wasn’t involved and didn’t do anything. Why write about that? He should have done it the day after the occurrence.”

Get the latest news from thewest.com.au in your inbox.

Sign up for our emails